Field Dispatch
#47 Gill & Andrew. The Body Image Industry
Trail notes
It's one of the questions we're asked most often, especially around our strength courses. Will I lose weight? Will I tone up? Will this change my body?
In this episode, Andrew and I go for a walk and talk through the many reasons why we deliberately avoid making those promises.
We talk about growing up in the 90s and the era of Heat magazine, celebrity "circle of shame" features and the diet culture, before exploring how today's fitness industry continues to market health through insecurity, before-and-after photos and unrealistic body ideals.
Drawing on Andrew's experience working in commercial gyms and then moving into public health, we discuss the difference between pain-point marketing and what the evidence tells us about lasting behaviour change.
We ramble around a few bit and touch on bodybuilding, social media, steroids, GLP-1 drugs, optimisation culture, AI-generated fitness content.
Rather than asking "How can I change my body?", perhaps a better question is:
"What do I want my body to help me do?"
In this episode
Why WildStrong doesn't use before-and-after photos
Growing up with 1990s diet culture and celebrity magazines
How commercial gyms are taught to market through people's insecurities
Pain points versus opportunity: what behaviour change research actually says
The illusion of control in modern fitness culture
Orthorexia, optimisation and the "spreadsheetification" of health
Why today's physique standards are so different from previous generations
Steroids, bodybuilding and changing expectations
Hugh Jackman, Hollywood and social media physiques
GLP-1 drugs, AI influencers and the future of body image
What people really mean when they ask if a programme will "tone" them
Why capability may be a more meaningful goal than aesthetics
Mentioned in this episode
Heat magazine's "Circle of Shame"
Kate Winslet and media coverage following Titanic
Joe Wicks
Eugene Sandow
Mr Universe and Mr Olympia
Hugh Jackman
GLP-1 medications (including Ozempic)
Orthorexia
COM-B behaviour change model
Social determinants of health
Kill All Normies by Angela Nagle
If you enjoyed this episode, we'd love it if you subscribed, left a review or shared it with someone who might find it useful.
Thank you!
Podbean